Football Dec 07, 2025

Crystal Palace struggling but Aston Villa thriving, so does European football really hurt Premier League form?

👤
By Admin
Sports Journalist
Crystal Palace struggling but Aston Villa thriving, so does European football really hurt Premier League form?

It's a widely-held belief that European football hurts Premier League form, but is it true or is it a myth? We take a look in this week's edition of Between the Lines.

The latest round of Premier League games fed the narrative that teams tend to struggle directly after their European fixtures.

Chelsea and Arsenal played out a ragged 1-1 draw at Stamford Bridge on Sunday following their respective Champions League victories over Barcelona and Bayern Munich in midweek.

Spurs, Crystal Palace and Nottingham Forest also showed signs of fatigue as they were beaten by sides who had free midweeks in Fulham, Manchester United and Brighton respectively.

Of the nine Premier League teams in Europe, only Liverpool and Newcastle won comfortably, with Manchester City needing a stoppage-time goal to see off Leeds and Aston Villa scraping a one-goal win over bottom-of-the-table Wolves.

But how have the Premier League's European representatives fared overall after their Champions League, Europa League and Conference League fixtures this season?

The chart below shows their fortunes have been mixed.

Crystal Palace, Nottingham Forest, Liverpool, Chelsea and Arsenal all have lower points-per-game averages after European nights compared to their other games.

But the other sides have fared much better, with Manchester City, Spurs, Newcastle and Aston Villa all recording higher points-per-game averages directly after their European assignments.

Having only won one of their six Premier League games after European fixtures this season, Palace have averaged just 0.8 points per game compared to 2.1 points per game in their other fixtures.

The 61-per-cent negative difference is the second-biggest for any Premier League side competing in Europe since the 2010/11 campaign.

Only Burnley in 2018/19 have seen a bigger negative difference in points per game after European fixtures. The Clarets drew one and lost three of their four games after Europa League fixtures that season as they failed to make it through the play-off rounds.

So why do sides like Burnley and Palace struggle?

A lack of squad depth is one issue when it comes to managing the extra workload presented by European qualification.

Oliver Glasner was outspoken on the subject after Palace's defeat to Manchester United on Sunday, bemoaning the club's failure to adequately strengthen their squad following their European qualification at the end of last season.

"We missed [the chance] to strengthen the depth of the squad in summer, and we knew the schedule, we knew that Ismaila [Sarr] would go to AFCON. Nothing happened, surprisingly," he said.

"When you play the first time in your history, European football, let's invest instead of save. We saved, and that's what we are facing."

Without rotation options trusted by Glasner, Palace have made fewer line-up changes than any other Premier League side this season, leading to fatigue among first-choice starters and contributing to their latest defeat.

It is worth noting that Forest, another side new to European competition in the Premier League era, have also struggled directly after their Europa League games this season.

While Palace have recorded one of the biggest negative differences in points per game after European fixtures this season, Villa have recorded the biggest positive difference on record.

Unai Emery's side have won all five of their games directly after Europa League fixtures this season, which makes for a 167-per-cent increase on their points-per-game average in their other fixtures.

Unlike Palace and Forest, Villa have had two years to adapt to the extra demands having played in the Champions League and Conference League in the last two seasons.

Last season, they struggled in their games after the Champions League, only winning four out of 11. But lessons have been learned, with Emery making better use of his squad to keep his players fresh and keep them on track domestically.

Newcastle are also managing the workload better. The 100-per-cent positive difference to their points per game after Champions League fixtures this season is the third-biggest by any side since 2010/11.

While Palace, Forest, Villa and Newcastle offer extreme examples, there is little difference between results after European games compared to other games on average.

Since 2010/11, Premier League sides have averaged 1.76 points after European games compared to 1.79 points in other games.

The widely-held belief that Europe negatively impacts Premier League form is more myth than reality.

Last week we had a dig into Thomas Frank's "extreme" style overhaul at Tottenham and explained why the former Brentford head coach is struggling to make it click.

Tags:

football news id:13477827

Share this article

Related Posts

York promoted to the EFL after incredible stoppage-time drama at Rochdale in top-of-table final day contest

York promoted to the EFL after incredible stoppage-time drama at Rochdale in top-of-table final day contest

Josh Stones scored an equaliser 13 minutes into added time that returned York to the Football League – with a dramatic 1-1 draw also featuring an inju...

Man City 2-1 Southampton: Pep Guardiola's men make FA Cup final for fourth consecutive year after mighty Saints scare

Man City 2-1 Southampton: Pep Guardiola's men make FA Cup final for fourth consecutive year after mighty Saints scare

Manchester City were given an almighty FA Cup scare by Southampton but came from behind to win 2-1 and make the final for the fourth year in a row.Cha...

Celtic go level with Scottish Premiership leaders Hearts before title rivals are in action on Sunday

Celtic go level with Scottish Premiership leaders Hearts before title rivals are in action on Sunday

Celtic moved level on points with Scottish Premiership leaders Hearts after a hard-fought 3-1 victory over Falkirk at Celtic Park.Martin O'Neill's sid...

Arsenal 1-0 Newcastle United: Gunners go three points clear of Man City with nervy win as Kai Havertz and Eberechi Eze suffer injury scares

Arsenal 1-0 Newcastle United: Gunners go three points clear of Man City with nervy win as Kai Havertz and Eberechi Eze suffer injury scares

Arsenal moved three points above Manchester City at the top of the Premier League with a nervy 1-0 win over Newcastle.Eberechi Eze scored the decisive...

Dundee United 3-0 Dundee: Will Ferry double seals derby win for hosts

Dundee United 3-0 Dundee: Will Ferry double seals derby win for hosts

Will Ferry was the home hero with a decisive derby double as Dundee United comfortably beat Dundee 3-0 at Tannadice.The wing-back netted in both halve...

Wolves 0-1 Tottenham: Joao Palhinha scores late on to give Spurs a Premier League lifeline at Molineux

Wolves 0-1 Tottenham: Joao Palhinha scores late on to give Spurs a Premier League lifeline at Molineux

Joao Palhinha poked in a late winner for Tottenham as they picked up their first Premier League victory of 2026 in a 1-0 win at Wolves that gives them...